Youth Focused Evaluation Topical Interest Group is for Evaluation About Youth, for Youth, and with Youth. The Youth Focused Evaluation TIG aims to collaboratively create learning spaces for all evaluators and researchers (adult and youth) that focus on the practices and outcomes of positive youth development and participatory approaches across informal and formal contexts. The YFE-TIG speaks to youth and adult evaluators’ and researchers’ unique needs by promoting the development and use of responsive tools and methods leading to practical and transformative outcomes for young people. The YFE-TIG helps youth and adult evaluators and researchers develop effective practices in professional development, program quality, measurement, ethics, youth participation, and amplifying youth voice and power. Ultimately, we want to support more profound youth-informed or youth-led evaluation and decision-making. This week’s posts are sponsored by the YFE-TIG.
Have you ever had to take a survey for school or work? How did it make you feel? Do you know how or if it was used? Surveys are often given out in school settings to elicit feedback about the student experience. However, in our experiences as students, surveys have not been helpful or humanizing and can often feel like a chore rather than mutually supporting personal and organizational learning. Surveys often feel like a dead-end process –just another hoop to jump through. That is what motivated us, Kyliegh Grant and Aaralyn Allin-Zayas, to reflect on how to improve evaluation tools, both in schools and in youth organizing contexts.
We want surveys and other forms of evaluations to be purposeful and support the people receiving the information. Through our participation in Voices of Healing, a community-based research collective working with youth of color across the Colorado Front Range, we have seen that many young people share this desire. In our participatory action research (PAR) project, Healing Approaches to Evaluation, we examined how youth experience surveys and found that their frustrations reflect larger problems with evaluation systems. To better understand this issue, we spent time learning from local youth organizing communities with experience in designing, distributing, and taking surveys.
Lessons Learned
As youth engaged in social justice, we recognize that traditional evaluations often fail to capture our lived experiences and ideas. Therefore, in our PAR project, we aimed to ground our community surveys in storytelling, to reflect and honor communities’ desire for meaningful evaluation. One community member described how evaluations could create space for feeling seen and valued:
“Being heard is something that all humans seek. And an evaluation can bring in that tool to reflect or a resource that makes them feel heard or a healing experience of being able to feel at peace.”
As highlighted by another community member, when evaluations are designed with this intention, they can move beyond data collection to become tools for accountability and collective learning:
“Evaluations can serve as a tool/resource/support for healing by not only giving communities the opportunity to determine for themselves by what measures they are staying accountable to their work and the culture in their organization but by serving as an instrument to gather and have meaningful conversations around the work itself.”
Ultimately, we believe that evaluations should be process-based to humanize communities and encourage growth. We center storytelling in our evaluative approaches because we recognize that storytelling and process-based approaches to gathering data challenge one-dimensional portraits or the flattening of people’s experiences. Evaluations should treat people’s stories with dignity and handle them with care. Imagine a survey experience where young people feel our voices truly matter – where feedback is not just collected but actively shapes the spaces we navigate. What if evaluations weren’t a dead-end, but a door to real conversations, reflections, and healing? That is the future we are working towards.
The American Evaluation Association is hosting YFE TIG Week with our colleagues in the Youth Focused Evaluation Topical Interest Group. The contributions all this week to AEA365 come from our YFE TIG members. Do you have questions, concerns, kudos, or content to extend this AEA365 contribution? Please add them in the comments section for this post on the AEA365 webpage so that we may enrich our community of practice. Would you like to submit an AEA365 Tip? Please send a note of interest to AEA365@eval.org. AEA365 is sponsored by the American Evaluation Association and provides a Tip-a-Day by and for evaluators. The views and opinions expressed on the AEA365 blog are solely those of the original authors and other contributors. These views and opinions do not necessarily represent those of the American Evaluation Association, and/or any/all contributors to this site.

I love how the authors concluded their blog with the question, “What if evaluations weren’t a dead-end, but a door to real conversations, reflections, and healing?” This is the kind of evaluation (and research) I want to do. The ideas about storytelling are super helpful. Thank you Kyliegh and Aaralyn!