Theories of Evaluation TIG Week: From Scarcity to Strength: Using ABCD to Reframe Evaluation in Human Services by Sandy Sheppard

Hello! I’m Sandy Sheppard, a community social worker and researcher (PhD, LMSW), working as a Senior Evaluation Associate for CCNY, Inc. in Buffalo, NY where I am committed to bringing an ABCD lens to all my evaluation work.

The Challenge

What happens when evaluation encounters systemic scarcity? In Project A, I was part of a team helping a community already devastated by disinvestment respond to racially motivated violence. In Project B, I’m part of a team investigating the feasibility of expanding overnight respite services for people with developmental disabilities (I/DD). In both cases, the easy path would be to document deficits; however, Asset-Based Community Development (ABCD) challenges me to see something more: assets already at work, capacities ready to be mobilized, and visions waiting to be amplified.

Using the ABCD Theory

The ABCD Institute describes Asset-Based Community Development (ABCD) as an approach that starts with the gifts, talents, skills, and resources already present in a community, rather than focusing on needs and gaps. In evaluation, this means asking: what is strong, not just what is wrong? ABCD shifts my lens from “problems to be solved” to “strengths to be connected,” and in doing so, transforms the role of evaluators into facilitators of possibility.

In Project A, as requested, we collected “needs data” after a tragedy. We only retroactively discovered an eight-point community-identified vision for thriving: mentorship opportunities, support for small businesses, community self-surveillance, and more. Our “needs focus” contributed to this insight to be overlooked.

I am purposefully applying the ABCD lens into Project B: scanning county-level feasibility indicators for expanding overnight respite. The need is clear—families require relief, and individuals with I/DD need safe, dignified spaces. The scarcity is also clear—the Direct Service Provider workforce is stretched thin, and overnight coverage is the hardest to sustain. ABCD challenges me to look beyond need and scarcity: Where are the assets? I found them, regionally, in:

  • Innovative recruitment and retention strategies: agencies revamping websites, simplifying applications, holding “on-the-spot” hiring events with food and music, and creating flexible relief staffing pools.
  • Higher education pipelines: state college micro credential programs, community college partnerships offering fully funded training, and DSP coaching that includes tuition, books, and materials.
  • Professional recognition: civil service associations working with state and national groups to provide financial bonuses for certification, and credentialing organizations embedding DSP knowledge into national career ladders.

These are not silver bullets. They are fragmented, often underfunded, and unevenly distributed, but seen through an asset-based lens, they represent nodes of strength in what looks, at first glance, like an impossible landscape.

Lessons Learned

  • ABCD does not deny scarcity—it reframes it. In the project examples I shared, the theory helped (or would have helped) me avoid collapsing into narratives of brokenness. Instead, it pushed (or would have pushed) me to document, connect, and amplify what is already happening.
  • ABCD must be paired with systemic critique: asset mapping alone will not fix wage inequities, structural disinvestment, or policy misalignment; however, when evaluators illuminate assets alongside challenges, communities and systems are better positioned to act.
Get involved

I’ve seen that even in contexts of scarcity—whether community recovery after violence or the strained human services workforce—assets are always present. As evaluators, our task is to help surface them, connect them, and make them visible to those with power to invest.

How are YOU using evaluation theory to move from scarcity narratives toward opportunity mapping in human services? I’d love to hear what you’re discovering.


The American Evaluation Association is hosting Theories of Evaluation TIG Week with our colleagues in the Theories of Evaluation Topical Interest Group. The contributions all this week to AEA365 come from our Theories of Evaluation TIG members. Do you have questions, concerns, kudos, or content to extend this aea365 contribution? Please add them in the comments section for this post on theaea365 webpageso that we may enrich our community of practice. Would you like to submit an aea365 Tip? Please send a note of interest to aea365@eval.org. aea365 is sponsored by theAmerican Evaluation Associationand provides a Tip-a-Day by and for evaluators. The views and opinions expressed on the AEA365 blog are solely those of the original authors and other contributors. These views and opinions do not necessarily represent those of the American Evaluation Association, and/or any/all contributors to this site.

1 thought on “Theories of Evaluation TIG Week: From Scarcity to Strength: Using ABCD to Reframe Evaluation in Human Services by Sandy Sheppard”

  1. This is a profound and much-needed perspective on the role of evaluators. I truly appreciate how you distinguish between denying scarcity and reframing it—it’s a critical nuance. Moving from ‘problems to be solved’ to ‘strengths to be connected’ is a powerful shift that honors the dignity and agency of the communities we serve. Thank you for sharing these concrete examples from Project A and B; they provide a great roadmap for others looking to adopt an ABCD lens!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.